QuantLogix

VDE vs XLE — ETF comparison

Two funds head-to-head: live engine reads, trailing performance, and holdings overlap from SEC filings. An engine-read comparison — not a recommendation.

VDE
Vanguard Energy ETF
46/100
NEUTRAL
$168.89 · -0.77% · Energy
Full ETF page →
VS
engine lead
XLE
State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF
54/100
BUY
$60.89 · -0.52% · Energy
Full ETF page →
Factor by factor — VDE (left) vs XLE (right)
64
Technical
68
46
Momentum
44
48
Fundamental
50
59
Options
—
36
Microstructure
40
Trailing performance — VDE (left) vs XLE (right)
+15.3%
6-month return
+17.6%
+51.7%
1-year return
+54.2%
+128.8%
5-year return
+132.2%
Holdings overlap — 52.1% by weight · 16 shared positions
14.11%
16.09%
6.01%
6.57%
4.15%
4.48%
4.05%
4.64%
3.67%
4.07%
2.92%
4.15%
2.33%
3.45%
2.31%
3.30%
Largest VDE-only positions: XOM 21.40% · LNG 2.28% · OVV 0.72% · DINO 0.64% · DTM 0.51%

From each fund's SEC N-PORT filing (2026-10-29 / 2026-08-28), computed on the 78 of 111 and 16 of 21 equity positions matched to the QuantLogix stock universe — a lower bound, never an estimate.

QuantLogix's 5-factor engine currently reads Vanguard Energy ETF (VDE) at 46/100 (neutral) and State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLE) at 54/100 (buy). XLE carries the stronger composite read by 8 points, led by technical at 68/100. VDE's strongest leg is technical at 64/100. On trailing price performance, XLE leads over the last year (+54.2% vs +51.7% for VDE). By filed portfolio weights, at least 52.1% of the two funds overlaps across 16 shared positions. Signals recompute throughout the trading day — the balance can shift with the tape.

Track XLE with free signal alerts Browse all 4,900+ ETF rankings
🤖 Want the deeper take? Pro runs a 10-agent AI debate on either name — 5 analysts, bull vs bear, a risk read, and a trader's verdict. See Pro →

Educational market analysis, not investment advice. QuantLogix does not provide personalized recommendations. VDE ETF page · XLE ETF page · ETF rankings · Equities Network · Verified track record